This post contains affiliate links.
Are you Team Sam’s Club or Team Costco? Or, are you like me and have both memberships?
Over the years, I’ve been gifted warehouse club memberships or bought them on my own. A lot of people wonder if warehouse club memberships are worth the price. Let’s break it down with two of the clubs in Wisconsin: Sam’s Club and Costco.
On the one hand, I’m a west-sider, which makes Sam’s Club more convenient. I got my membership through the Groupon deal below and shopped there once. While I did save money on some of the items I bought, I’m sort of a Crunchy Granola-type mom and did not see a whole lot of organic items. But there are some items that I can get there that aren’t available at Costco. I’ll still use my membership from time-to-time and have saved more than what I paid for the membership, so I am a satisfied customer.
When Costco came to Green Bay, I tried it out and went in on a membership with my mother. At the time, I didn’t find the need to shop there a lot because I shopped at Amazon and Target a lot. Now, though, I’m trying to rely less on the ‘Zon, so I took advantage of the deal offered below and have already saved a ton. Their price on a discounted Bosch dishwasher was worth of the price of membership alone. There are lots of organic options on everything from fruits and vegetables to granola cereal and obscenely good deals on staples like eggs and butter. I specifically added my college-aged son to my membership instead of my husband so he could go to the cafe and get the $1.50 hot dog and soda combo.
Both Costco and Sam’s Club offer some discounts that the other one doesn’t offer. Costco’s annual 2% Rebate Reward is great because I can just roll it onto my renewal and pays for itself. Sam;s Club has
Sam’s Club Plus Membership – $120 (Includes Walmart+ Membership)
$120 available through my affiliate link here -> Sam’s Club Memberships Here are the benefits to the Plus Membership:
- Plus Membership – $120 (Walmart+ included)
- All the benefits of Club plus premium perks:
- 2% Sam’s Cash on qualifying in-club and curbside purchases (up to $750/year)
- Free Shipping on most items with no minimum
- Free Same-Day Delivery on eligible $50+ orders
- Early Shopping Hours starting at 8 a.m., beat the crowds by two full hours
- Pharmacy savings on generic prescriptions
- Optical discounts frames from $59, 40% off additional pairs
- Curbside Pickup always free for Plus members
- Plus now includes Walmart+:
- Free same-day delivery from Walmart*
- 10¢ off per gallon at 17k+ stations**
- Video Streaming Choice included*** (Peacock or Paramount+)
Sam’s Club Membership – $60
- Club Membership – $60
- Full access to all ~600 Sam’s Club locations and SamsClub.com
- Includes 1 complimentary Household Card
- Members-only fuel savings at the pump
- Scan & Go: scan items on your phone and skip every checkout line
- Free Curbside Pickup on eligible $50+ orders
- Instant Savings and special offers on top of low prices
- Accepts all major credit cards (Visa, Mastercard, Amex, Discover)
Costco, like Sam’s Club, has two different kinds of membership. Here’s a closer look at what each type offers. Costco Membership as low as $65 + $45 Voucher
Costco Gold Star Membership + $45 Digital Costco Shop Card
- Access to over 600 Costco warehouses (900+ worldwide) and Costco.com
- Primary Membership + Household Card included
- Member-exclusive value at Costco Gas Stations
- Costco Pharmacy, Optical & Hearing Aid Centers
- Delivery, Installation and Haul Away
- AT&T and T-Mobile Exclusive Savings
Costco Executive Membership + $45 Digital Costco Shop Card
All Gold Star benefits, plus:
- Annual 2% Reward (up to $1,250/yr) * on qualified purchases (I got a nice rebate check that will go towards my membership renewal
- Early shopping hours from 9 a.m.
- $10/month credit on Instacart Same-Day delivery
- Enhanced Costco Travel rewards on vacations & cruises
- Member value at Costco Gas Stations
This post contains affiliate links. That means I may earn a few pennies if you purchase any books mentioned in this post, at no additional cost to you. Monies earned offset the costs of web hosting. Thank you for supporting this blog!
Do you like what you see here on Wisconsin Consumer? Subscribe to updates below! You’ll get an email around 4pm every day I publish a post. I never sell your information, and you can unsubscribe at any time. If you like what you see on Wisconsin Consumer, please tell your friends! As always, thanks for the support!

[…] When my mother was still alive, we split the cost of a Sam’s Club or Costco membership. She wanted the great prices but didn’t need the large quantities. So, we split the purchases and she took as much as she needed, and then I got the rest. You might know someone who has a membership and would be willing to let you piggy-back on to their membership. See my article Are Warehouse Clubs Worth the Membership Price? Exploring the Perks of Costco and Sam’s Club […]